Pinpointing the best player ever chosen at each pick during the NFL draft—from the first overall selection down to the final pick—reveals a captivating journey through draft history. Since the common draft era kicked off in 1967, the league has witnessed legendary talent surface from virtually every spot on the board. Here’s a deep dive into who stands out as the top draft pick at every position, weighing skill, success, and lasting impact.
How the Picks Were Evaluated
Determining the “best” draft pick requires balancing both talent and achievement. This evaluation weighs accolades like MVP awards, All-Pro selections, Super Bowl victories, individual statistics, career longevity, and peak performances. While championship rings hold considerable weight, the analysis also recognizes players who dominated during their careers regardless of team success.
Only players’ impacts while with their drafting teams were emphasized—meaning those who thrived and contributed long-term value for the team that selected them had the edge over career journeymen. Positions were fairly assessed without disproportionately favoring quarterbacks, except in clear-cut cases.
Highlights from Round 1
1. Peyton Manning, QB (1998)
Among numerous Hall of Famers selected first overall, Peyton Manning claims the best overall pick with five MVP titles, two Super Bowl wins on different teams, and still-standing records for yards and touchdowns in a single season. His illustrious career ranks as one of the most accomplished in NFL history.
2. Lawrence Taylor, OLB (1981)
Lawrence Taylor, often regarded as the greatest defensive player ever, stands out as the best second overall pick. A two-time Defensive Player of the Year and one of only two defensive MVP award winners, his relentless pass rushing helped redefine linebacker play.
3. Barry Sanders, RB (1989)
Tough competition came from all-pro offensive linemen like Anthony Munoz and Joe Thomas, but Barry Sanders takes the nod for his brilliant running style, game-changing ability, and status as the greatest Detroit Lion in franchise history despite retiring early.
4. Walter Payton, RB (1975)
Known affectionately as “Sweetness,” Walter Payton‘s profound influence both on and off the field, including a career rushing total surpassing 16,000 yards, makes him the most valuable fourth overall pick in NFL annals.
5. Deion Sanders, CB (1989)
Among elite players like Junior Seau and LaDainian Tomlinson, cornerback Deion Sanders earns the top spot owing to his unique two-way play, six All-Pro appearances, and two Super Bowl championships — including Defensive Player of the Year honors.
10. Patrick Mahomes, QB (2017)
The first active player on the list, Patrick Mahomes has already amassed two MVP awards, three Super Bowl victories, and multiple Super Bowl MVPs. He’s on pace to challenge for the title of the greatest quarterback ever.
Noteworthy Picks in Later Rounds
33. Brett Favre, QB (1991)
Drafted 33rd overall, Brett Favre emerged as one of the NFL’s most electrifying passers and a three-time MVP, despite the Falcons never capitalizing on his talents.
56. Osi Umenyiora, DE (2003)
Near the middle rounds, Osi Umenyiora is recognized for his key role in two Super Bowl-winning New York Giants teams and an impressive mix of regular-season and playoff performances.
97. Kerby Joseph, S (2022)
The most recent draft selection on this top-pick list, Kerby Joseph made an immediate impact by leading the league in interceptions and being named a first-team All-Pro.
188. Danny Trevathan, LB (2012)
An example of late-round value, Danny Trevathan highlights how productive and impactful players can emerge deep in the draft, making pick number 188 the best ever at that slot.
262. Brock Purdy, QB (2022)
Capping off the list, Brock Purdy is noted as possibly the most famous seventh-round selection ever, exemplifying how a final draft pick can rise to prominence.
Summary of Methodology and Patterns
- Player success was measured primarily by combining individual excellence with team achievements.
- Preference was given to players who contributed extensively to the drafting team’s success.
- While quarterbacks usually dominate such lists, exceptional players from other positions often rose above their counterparts.
- This comprehensive ranking covers every draft spot from the common era using the current seven-round format (picks 1 through 262).
- Some selections were close calls, reflecting the draft’s unpredictability and the depth of NFL talent.
This review shines a spotlight on players who became legends despite where they were chosen, illuminating the unpredictability and excitement of the NFL Draft over the decades.
