The spotlight in NFL Draft discussions usually gravitates toward the projected top-50 prospects, but the league routinely discovers talented players selected in later rounds—or those who slip through entirely as undrafted free agents. Take last year’s hidden gem, Kansas State cornerback Jacob Parrish, who emerged as a standout mid-round pick. Size concerns lingered around him, yet Tampa Bay took a chance at No. 84, and he quickly developed into one of the most impressive rookie corners during the season’s first half.
While this year’s crop of overlooked talent runs deep, here are eight mid-round sleepers who might fly under the radar in early rounds but carry the tools to contribute right away.
Chris Johnson, Cornerback, San Diego State
Johnson ranks among the most undervalued prospects available, having delivered stellar play for the Aztecs this season. He’s allowed just 40% completion rates when targeted while snagging three picks across six games. Despite seeing indirect interest from SEC, Big Ten, and Big 12 programs during last offseason’s recruiting cycle, Johnson decided to remain at San Diego State, viewing it as his clearest path to the pros.
At 6 feet and 182 pounds, Johnson brings a lean, linear frame combined with exceptional short-area quickness. His athletic ability lets him shadow receivers effectively in press situations. While he typically operates on the perimeter, he slides inside during nickel formations and shows aggression supporting the run game.
The primary question mark surrounding Johnson’s NFL ceiling involves his straight-line speed, which occasionally creates concerns on tape. Scouts will keep close tabs on his spring workout numbers, but his film reveals an NFL-ready corner with special teams potential.
Logan Taylor, Offensive Tackle/Guard, Boston College
While left tackle Jude Bowry commands much of the attention along Boston College’s front, Taylor has displayed consistent growth and flexibility. Standing 6-foot-6½ and weighing 309 pounds with arms extending past 34 inches, Taylor brings starting experience at both tackle and guard positions. His projection leans toward interior line work at the next level given his moderate lateral movement.
The Canadian-born lineman carries an intriguing background—he switched from defensive line with just one year of offensive line experience before arriving at college. Beyond his physical attributes, his competitive fire, football IQ, and positional adaptability make him an attractive target for NFL coaching staffs.
Arion Carter, Linebacker, Tennessee
Leading the SEC in tackles, Carter consistently pops on film. He possesses natural football instincts, showcasing ability in run stuffing, pass rushing, and coverage situations. His size and speed measure as average by NFL linebacker standards, but his relentless motor and quick processing help bridge those gaps.
Currently projected as a third-round selection, Carter remains a true junior and could face a significant career choice after this season wraps up.
Caleb Tiernan, Offensive Tackle, Northwestern
Now in his third campaign as Northwestern’s starting left tackle, Tiernan is playing some of his finest football. His Week 3 showing against Oregon ranked among the cleanest offensive line performances witnessed this season. With a steady demeanor, Tiernan shines in pass protection, making it tough for rushers to break through.
While some inconsistencies surface in his run blocking, he utilizes sound angles and fundamentals. Initially considered a Day 3 selection, Tiernan has worked his way into top-100 prospect discussions and keeps building momentum.
Bryce Boettcher, Linebacker, Oregon
A former walk-on who also played college baseball, Boettcher’s heart and grit are hard to ignore. At 6-foot-1, 226 pounds with 31-inch arms, the Oregon native falls slightly below typical NFL linebacker measurements, which becomes apparent during physical battles.
Even so, Boettcher’s fearless mentality, constant energy, and quickness help him on every down. NFL evaluations span a wide range, but he’s likely to hear his name called within the first four rounds.
Kaytron Allen, Running Back, Penn State
While teammate Nicholas Singleton possesses more elite speed at 220 pounds with a 4.3 forty time, Allen has emerged as Penn State’s primary ball carrier—a role that appears to have interim head coach Terry Smith’s backing.
After sharing touches early this season, Allen received a career-high 28 carries against Iowa, churning out 5.2 yards per attempt while Singleton managed just six carries for 2.5 yards per rush. Allen may not have breakaway speed, but his sharp, polished cuts and sturdy running approach at 5-foot-11, 216 pounds position him as a dependable NFL backfield option.
Niki Prongos, Offensive Tackle, Stanford
Despite being relatively new to football, Prongos is climbing draft boards rapidly. He didn’t start playing until his senior year of high school (missing most of it due to injury after just three games), then spent two seasons at UCLA primarily as a backup before breaking through as a starter in 2024. Following his recent transfer to Stanford, he’s held his own at left tackle.
While another college season might help his continued physical development, Prongos’ smooth athleticism and hand placement techniques have earned comparisons to Bernhard Raimann, making him an intriguing prospect.
Justin Joly, Tight End, NC State
Once a raw, 190-pound wide receiver recruit, Joly has evolved into a muscular 250-pound tight end and potential top-100 pick. At 6-foot-3, he demonstrates impressive strength in both blocking assignments and contested catches downfield.
Joly excels as a route runner, particularly by dropping his center of gravity at breaks against man coverage and finding soft spots in zone schemes. His skill set brings to mind former NFL standout Jonnu Smith.
Author: Dane Brugler, national NFL writer for The Athletic and expert in NFL Draft coverage.
Follow Dane on Twitter: @DPBrugler
